Irish actor Paul Mescal has pushed back against comparisons between his upcoming film, “The History of Sound,” and the iconic “Brokeback Mountain.” Mescal stated that the only commonality lies in both films featuring characters who share time together in a tent. However, the narrative diverges significantly as it follows the characters David and Alan, who are separated when David is drafted into World War I. Their reunion sees them hiking across Maine in search of oral tradition songs to record, ultimately shaping their lives in profound ways.
Critics have noted thematic similarities, with Variety dubbing it “‘Brokeback Mountain’ on sedatives.” The Guardian also weighed in, offering a less favorable review, describing it as a “quasi-Brokeback Mountain film” with a tone of sadness, earning it two out of five stars. Mescal finds these comparisons not only frustrating but also limiting, emphasizing that “The History of Sound” celebrates the characters’ love rather than inflicting repression, which was a central theme in Ang Lee’s film.
Director Oliver Hermanus echoed Mescal’s sentiment, asserting that resorting to such comparisons reflects a lack of originality in discussions surrounding contemporary LGBTQ+ narratives in film. Mescal, who has previously gained recognition for his roles in “All of Us Strangers” and “Aftersun,” is drawn to complex characters, which he describes as a natural instinct guiding his choices.
As “The History of Sound” approaches its release, it stands as a testament to modern love stories that highlight connection and exploration rather than confinement. The film’s portrayal of resilience and emotional depth amidst historical events brings a hopeful outlook for audiences, signaling a shift towards more diverse narratives that embrace love’s complexities.
This new project, along with Mescal’s growing filmography, continues to showcase the evolving landscape of cinema that seeks to honor varied human experiences.
Leave a comment