A New Zealand government committee has put forth a recommendation for the temporary suspension of three Indigenous lawmakers from parliament following their performance of a haka during discussions of a controversial bill last year. The Privileges Committee has advised that Te Pati Maori co-leaders Debbie Ngarewa-Packer and Rawiri Waititi face a suspension of 21 days, while fellow member Hana-Rawhiti Maipi-Clarke is suggested to receive a seven-day suspension for allegedly intimidating a member of the house.
The report indicates that while performances of haka, a traditional Māori ceremonial dance, are not unusual in parliamentary settings, the lawmakers did not obtain the necessary permission from the Speaker beforehand. The parliamentary vote required to confirm these suspensions is anticipated to pass with backing from the ruling conservative coalition.
This move follows the lawmakers’ and opposition Labour Party member Pene Henare’s haka performance prior to a vote on a bill that sought to reinterpret a longstanding treaty between the British and Māori, dating back 184 years. Ngarewa-Packer reportedly made a gesture resembling a finger gun during this time, which has also come under scrutiny.
Te Pati Maori expressed disapproval of the proposed sanctions, labeling them as the most severe handed down by the committee. In their statement, they noted, “When Tangata whenua (Indigenous people) resist, colonial powers reach for maximum penalty.” Judith Collins, the ruling coalition member who leads the Privileges Committee, condemned the actions, asserting the right to vote without disruption is fundamental to parliamentary democracy.
Despite the controversy, similar instances in other regions highlight ongoing tensions within legislative bodies globally. For example, in Fiji, there have been recent instances of discord among MPs, with derogatory remarks exchanged in parliament, indicating a broader issue of maintaining respectful discourse in governance.
These events underscore the importance of a respectful and constructive environment within parliamentary processes, emphasizing the need for dialogue that honors democratic principles. The hope is that discussions following these incidents can lead to improvements in conduct, accommodating the voices of Indigenous representatives within political frameworks. Ultimately, fostering a culture of respect and understanding may help to bridge the gap between traditional practices and contemporary governance challenges.
Leave a comment