High Court Judge Justice Mohammed Mackie has ruled that the iTaukei Lands and Fisheries Commission’s designation of Ratu Vuniyani Navuniuci as the rightful titleholder of Tui Nadi was irregular, void, and of no effect. This ruling, delivered in Lautoka on Tuesday, represents a crucial development regarding land rights in Fiji.
The decision originated from an Amended Notice of Motion submitted by Ratu Asiveni Dawai on March 10, 2023. Justice Mackie criticized previous decisions made by the iTaukei Lands Appeals Tribunal on June 1, 2018, and the TLFC on December 5, 2017, which had affirmed Ratu Vuniyani Navuniuci’s title. The Judge found these rulings to be unreasonable, unlawful, and marred by bad faith, adversely affecting Ratu Dawai.
Importantly, Justice Mackie’s ruling occurred despite a prior court order from May 12, 2005, that prevented the TLFC from questioning the rightful holder of the Tui Nadi title. This judgement underscores ongoing discussions around land rights, particularly within the iTaukei community, and echoes other ancestral land cases, such as disputes raised by the Nauluvatu clan in Suva.
Fiji’s history of land ownership issues is rooted in its colonial past, with court cases revealing ongoing struggles for indigenous rights and acknowledgment. Justice Mackie’s ruling could bolster indigenous land claims, paving the way for more favorable outcomes for communities affected by these disputes.
This legal decision brings hope to individuals and clans in Fiji seeking justice for their land rights, illustrating the power of judicial intervention in addressing long-standing challenges over ancestral territories. It highlights the potential for progress as communities advocate for recognition and justice in their land claims.
Leave a comment