Justice Minister Siromi Turaga has clarified that the commutation of George Speight’s death sentence to life imprisonment in 2002 does not constitute a pardon. This statement comes amid increasing public scrutiny over the legality of Speight’s recent presidential pardon.
Turaga addressed concerns from critics, many of whom are questioning the possibility of Speight receiving a second pardon, as this would violate constitutional law. He explained that the decision to commute Speight’s death sentence was made in 2002, converting it to life imprisonment. A commutation reduces the sentence but does not eliminate the conviction or absolve the individual of the crime.
“When the death penalty was abolished by law, our constitution prohibited capital punishment, including hanging. This change applied not only to one person but to all those sentenced to death, converting their sentences to life imprisonment,” Turaga stated.
His clarification follows last week’s announcement regarding Speight’s presidential pardon. Turaga affirmed that due diligence was exercised in determining the legality of this release. He noted that other individuals convicted prior to the current government had also been released early, suggesting a clearer process for mercy now exists.
The presidential pardon allows Speight the possibility of freedom after more than twenty years in prison and has sparked mixed reactions across the country. Turaga expressed his belief that Speight deserves the pardon.
“It is not simply a legal issue; he deserves it just like everyone else,” Turaga said.
Ratu Viliame Seruvakula, Chair of the Great Council of Chiefs, urged the public to accept the release of the leader of the 2000 coup, stating that he has served his time. He drew on Nelson Mandela’s perspective on forgiveness and moving forward, emphasizing the importance of letting go of past grievances to achieve freedom.
Speight was among seven individuals pardoned and released last week, which also included Shane Stevens, a prominent figure in the violent mutiny at the Queen Elizabeth Barracks in 2000.