The recent appointment of Barbara Malimali as the Commissioner of the Fiji Independent Commission Against Corruption (FICAC) has sparked criticism from Senior Opposition Member of Parliament Jone Usamate, who described the decision as inappropriate and troubling.
While Mr. Usamate expressed no personal grievances against Ms. Malimali and supports women’s leadership in key roles, he raised concerns about the perceived lack of transparency and accountability in the appointment process. He suggested that the principles of good governance appear to have been ignored.
He emphasized the importance of the Constitutional Offices Commission (COC) ensuring a thorough review of candidates, questioning whether the Judicial Service Commission (JSC) followed similar standards in this specific case.
Mr. Usamate pointed out that Ms. Malimali’s appointment warranted further scrutiny given her prior investigation status, which should have led both the JSC and the President’s Office to reconsider her suitability for the role.
He also questioned the COC regarding Ms. Malimali’s resignation from her position as chair of the Electoral Commission, asking whether proper notice had been given. Furthermore, he demanded clarity on the instructions given to the Acting Deputy Commissioner Francis Puleiwai regarding the decision not to pursue formal charges against politician Biman Prasad, labeling it a severe abuse of office that requires immediate independent investigation.
Mr. Usamate underscored the need for good governance to remain foundational to a stable and effective government, challenging the notion that investigations into Cabinet Ministers might be viewed as malicious acts. He questioned whether any individual in Fiji was above scrutiny, invoking George Orwell’s commentary on equality.