Minister for Women, Children and Social Protection Lynda Tabuya’s call for the reintroduction of the death penalty for large-scale drug trafficking has sparked significant criticism. Ketan Lal, Shadow Minister for Justice from the Group of 16 (G16), expressed that Fiji should focus on implementing life sentences for rapists and ensuring justice for survivors rather than advocating for capital punishment.
Lal voiced disappointment that Tabuya, who is responsible for protecting vulnerable groups, would support such an extreme response. He emphasized the need for her office to advocate for the rights and empowerment of those affected by serious crimes, particularly sexual violence, which has devastating and lasting effects on victims.
He highlighted that rape is an extremely serious crime requiring immediate and effective legal responses. Lal argued that the nation’s efforts should be directed toward establishing a legal framework that guarantees timely justice for sexual violence victims while safeguarding the rights of all individuals.
While acknowledging the necessity to combat drug trafficking, he insisted that this should occur within the limits of the Constitution and human rights commitments. He cautioned against adopting measures that could be unconstitutional and ineffective, advocating instead for stronger laws addressing crimes like rape.
Lal also noted that while drug trafficking is a significant issue, proposing the death penalty contradicts Fiji’s constitutional values and international obligations. He referenced Article 8 of Fiji’s Constitution, which protects the right to life and prohibits cruel treatment.
Reinstating the death penalty would violate essential human rights and compromise the integrity of Fiji’s justice system, which is built on human dignity and the rule of law. He reiterated that Fiji’s adherence to international agreements opposing the death penalty is a testament to its commitment to human rights globally. Lal warned that any steps toward reinstating such a severe measure would undermine Fiji’s international reputation and moral authority.