Minister for Women, Children and Social Protection, Lynda Tabuya’s call for the death penalty for large-scale drug traffickers has sparked controversy. Ketan Lal, Shadow Minister for Justice from the Group of 16 (G16), criticized the proposal, suggesting that Fiji should prioritize life sentences for rapists and advocate for laws that deliver justice to survivors instead of considering capital punishment.
Lal expressed disappointment that Tabuya, who oversees a portfolio dedicated to vulnerable populations, would support such a severe measure. He emphasized that her role should focus on protecting and empowering those who are most vulnerable, including victims of violent crimes like rape. “Rape inflicts profound damage and creates lasting scars,” he stated, highlighting the urgency for a response that reflects the seriousness of the crime.
He called for a legal framework that guarantees quick and assured justice for sexual violence victims while safeguarding the rights of all individuals. “Our focus should shift from reinstating the death penalty to advocating for the lives and rights of those who have endured the most hardship,” he said.
Lal acknowledged the need for vigorous action against drug trafficking but insisted this must occur within the framework of the Constitution and human rights commitments. He warned against allowing fear to lead to unconstitutional and ineffective measures. Instead, he urged a strengthening of laws against crimes like rape, ensuring justice and upholding the rights of all Fijians.
While recognizing drug trafficking as a serious offense, Lal contended that proposing the death penalty contradicts Fiji’s constitutional values and international responsibilities. He pointed out that the Constitution guarantees the right to life and protects against cruel treatment. He noted that reinstating capital punishment would violate these fundamental rights and damage the integrity of the justice system, which is built on human dignity and the rule of law.
Lal reinforced that Fiji’s commitment to international agreements opposing the death penalty showcases the nation’s dedication to human rights globally. He warned that any move to reinstate such a severe punishment would regressive, jeopardizing Fiji’s international reputation and moral standing.