The appointment of Barbara Malimali as the new FICAC Commissioner has faced scrutiny from Opposition Member Jone Usamate, who argues that the principles of good governance have been overlooked. Usamate expressed concerns in a statement, stating, “The appointment feels all wrong, and it seems inappropriate. I support women in important positions, but the ideals of transparency and accountability seem to have been ignored.”
He pointed out that the Constitutional Offices Commission typically relies on an independent team to evaluate applications, ensuring the selection of the most qualified candidates. “Did the Judicial Services Commission (JSC) utilize such a team during this hiring process?” he questioned, emphasizing the JSC’s responsibility to uphold public confidence in independent institutions, even if it may conflict with their interests.
Usamate acknowledged that while Malimali has been recognized for her qualifications, with Acting Chief Justice Salesi Temo noting she received the highest score of 141, it remains unclear if comprehensive due diligence was carried out regarding ongoing investigations. He suggested that her appointment should have been postponed until any allegations against her were clarified, stating the significant impact of the FICAC Commissioner’s role demands careful handling to avoid compromising public trust.
Additionally, Usamate challenged the Constitutional Offices Commission regarding Malimali’s status with the Electoral Commission, questioning whether she had formally resigned and completed any required notice period. He also raised concerns about an incident involving Acting Deputy Commissioner Ms. Francis Puleiwai and the lack of formal charges against Hon Biman Prasad, calling for an independent investigation, possibly by police.
“Ms. Malimali should have exercised better judgment,” Usamate concluded, arguing that taking on the role while under investigation damages both FICAC’s and her own reputation. In response, Malimali labeled it irresponsible for critics to question the actions of the JSC, which comprises respected members of the judiciary.