Former Chief Justice Sir Clifford Grant, in his farewell address on April 6, 1978, honored retiring Supreme Court judge Mr. Justice Stuart, describing him as a devoted legal professional whose contributions to the Supreme Court were significant. This tribute was made during a special session of the Supreme Court of Fiji in Suva to commemorate Mr. Justice Stuart’s retirement.
Sir Clifford highlighted that Mr. Justice Stuart practiced law in Fiji for 35 years prior to his appointment to the Supreme Court in 1973. He also held the position of president of the Fiji Law Society from 1962 to 1964 and was active in community service throughout his legal career.
At the time of his retirement, Mr. Justice Stuart was 68 years old, the age mandated by Parliament for Supreme Court judges to step down. “I deeply regret that we are to be deprived of his extensive knowledge of the law, his humanity, and his wisdom,” Sir Clifford remarked, emphasizing that the judge’s exit from the Bench would be a significant loss.
Sir Clifford noted that Mr. Justice Stuart stood out in a profession that has historically faced public skepticism. He referenced the long-standing ridicule lawyers have encountered, citing how figures like Shakespeare and poet Samuel Taylor Coleridge have portrayed them unfavorably. Despite these negative perceptions, Sir Clifford expressed that once a lawyer ascends to the Bench, they are viewed with respect and their previous actions are often overlooked.
Regarding Mr. Justice Stuart, Sir Clifford asserted that there was nothing to forgive, as he brought to the role of judge all the virtues necessary for the position, particularly his dedication, thoroughness, and diligence.